Shelter Island Hotels

Step into the inviting embrace of The Rams Head Inn where rustic elegance meets coastal allure. Nestled among lush landscapes, this historic inn offers a warm atmosphere and personalized service that makes every guest feel at home. Enjoy our cozy accommodations that blend classic charm with modern comforts. Savor delectable dishes crafted from local ingredients in our charming dining room. Whether you’re exploring the island or simply unwinding by the fire, The Rams Head Inn is your perfect escape.

Embrace the tranquility of Sunset Beach Hotel where the sun kisses the horizon and the waves serenade your senses. This hidden gem offers a unique blend of coastal charm and modern luxury. Relax in our spacious rooms with stunning ocean views and indulge in gourmet dining that celebrates local flavors. Whether you seek adventure or relaxation, Sunset Beach Hotel is your perfect sanctuary on Shelter Island.

Discover the unique ambiance of The Chequit where history intertwines with modern comfort. Nestled in the heart of Shelter Island, this charming hotel invites you to relax and rejuvenate. With its beautifully appointed rooms and lush gardens, The Chequit is the ideal destination for those seeking a peaceful escape. Enjoy delightful dining options and explore the nearby beaches for a perfect blend of relaxation and adventure.