The 1901 Grill

The 1901 Grill is a classic Shelter Island restaurant and bar, offering well-crafted American grill fare in a historic setting that nods to the island’s rich past. The menu features all the grill classics done right — prime burgers, fresh seafood, grilled steaks, seasonal salads, and hearty sandwiches — along with a bar program of craft cocktails, local beers, and a thoughtful wine list. The atmosphere is warm and convivial, making it an equally great choice for a casual weeknight dinner, a leisurely weekend lunch, or a gathering with friends after a day on the water. Named for the year the property was established, The 1901 Grill carries a sense of history that adds to its considerable charm. A reliable, satisfying choice on Shelter Island NY’s dining scene and a favorite among regulars who know the island well.