STARs Café

STARs Café is a welcoming neighborhood café on Shelter Island, offering great coffee, freshly prepared food, and a relaxed atmosphere that makes it a natural gathering spot for locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re starting your morning with an espresso and a pastry, grabbing a quick lunch before the ferry, or settling in for a leisurely afternoon with a good book, STARs Café delivers the kind of comfortable, unhurried experience that makes island life so appealing. The menu features fresh salads, sandwiches, soups, and seasonal specials made with care and quality ingredients. The staff is friendly and the setting is warm and inviting. Part café, part community hub, STARs Café has earned its place as one of Shelter Island NY’s most cherished everyday destinations. A great spot to recharge between adventures on the island.