Shelter Island House

Shelter Island House is a beautifully appointed boutique hotel in Shelter Island Heights, offering graciously sized rooms with spa bathrooms, chic décor, and local art in an intimate, welcoming setting. The hotel features a seasonal outdoor pool, complimentary Wi-Fi and bicycles, and the kind of personalized service that makes every guest feel like a valued regular. Shelter Island House also operates The West Neck Guesthouse nearby — a charming companion property with seven private king-bedded rooms just a short stroll away. Together, the two properties offer some of the finest accommodation on Shelter Island NY. Conveniently located in the Heights, guests are steps from boutique shopping, great restaurants, and the island’s most scenic walking routes. Perfect for couples, small groups, and anyone seeking a stylish, unhurried East End retreat.