Opties and Dinghies

Opties and Dinghies is Shelter Island’s most nautically spirited bar and restaurant, offering cold drinks, casual food, and a laid-back waterfront atmosphere that perfectly captures the easy, sun-soaked vibe of island living. Named with a nod to the small sailboats that dot the island’s harbors, Opties and Dinghies draws a mix of boaters, beachgoers, and locals who come for the cold beer, the fresh food, and the unbeatable setting. The menu keeps things casual and satisfying — think burgers, sandwiches, fresh seafood bites, and bar snacks that pair perfectly with a cold drink on a warm afternoon. The crowd is friendly and the setting is genuinely beautiful. Whether you’re pulling up by boat or arriving after the ferry, Opties and Dinghies is one of those Shelter Island NY spots that makes you wonder why you ever live anywhere else.