Marie Eiffel Market

Marie Eiffel Market is a cherished Shelter Island institution, a French-inspired café and gourmet market that has been delighting islanders and visitors for years with its exceptional pastries, fresh sandwiches, artisan grocery selections, and wonderful coffee. The market side features carefully chosen imported and local goods — cheeses, charcuterie, specialty pantry items, fresh produce, and wines — making it one of the best spots on Shelter Island for stocking up on quality ingredients. The café side serves freshly made breakfast and lunch items throughout the day, with croissants, quiches, salads, and seasonal specials that reflect a genuine love of good food. The atmosphere is warm and European in spirit — unhurried, welcoming, and full of good smells. A must-visit destination on any trip to Shelter Island NY, and a daily ritual for many lucky enough to call the island home.