Heights Cafe and Wine Bar

Heights Cafe and Wine Bar is one of Shelter Island Heights’ most inviting spots, offering a carefully curated wine list, creative small plates, and a relaxed neighborhood atmosphere that makes it the ideal destination for a casual evening on the island. The wine selection spans Old World and New World producers with a focus on interesting, food-friendly bottles by the glass and bottle. The menu of small plates and light bites is designed to complement the wine program perfectly — think charcuterie, cheese boards, seasonal salads, and simple but satisfying savory dishes. The atmosphere is warm and convivial, drawing a mix of locals, weekenders, and visitors who appreciate good wine and good company. Located in the heart of Shelter Island Heights NY, it’s a short drive from both ferry landings and well worth seeking out.