Eccentric Bagel

Eccentric Bagel is Shelter Island’s go-to spot for fresh-baked bagels, creative breakfast sandwiches, and great coffee in a fun, welcoming setting. Whether you’re loading up before a day at the beach, grabbing a quick bite after stepping off the ferry, or treating yourself to a leisurely morning meal, Eccentric Bagel has exactly what you’re looking for. The bagels are made fresh daily and come loaded with creative toppings and housemade spreads that go well beyond the ordinary. The menu also features wraps, salads, and lunch options for midday visitors. The vibe is relaxed and friendly — the kind of place that immediately makes you feel at home on Shelter Island. A beloved morning ritual for locals and a happy discovery for visitors. Located conveniently on Shelter Island NY near the ferry.