Dandy Liquors

Dandy Liquors is Shelter Island’s go-to destination for wine, beer, spirits, and everything you need to stock a summer house bar or pick up a great bottle for dinner. Located at 43 North Ferry Road, it’s conveniently situated right in the heart of the island’s main commercial strip, easy to reach from both ferry landings. The selection is well-curated for a store of its size, with a solid wine section that includes a good range of East End producers, local craft beers, and a comprehensive spirits selection. The staff is knowledgeable and happy to help with recommendations for any occasion. Whether you’re arriving for a weekend and need to stock up, or simply picking up a bottle of rosé for the beach, Dandy Liquors is the reliable, friendly choice on Shelter Island NY. Open Monday through Saturday, with Sunday hours available.