Commander Cody's Seafood

Commander Cody’s Seafood is a Shelter Island institution, serving the freshest local seafood in a casual, laid-back atmosphere that perfectly captures the spirit of island life. Whether you’re craving a bowl of creamy clam chowder, a lobster roll overflowing with fresh meat, crispy fried clams, or grilled fish straight from the day’s catch, Commander Cody’s delivers the real deal. The menu is a celebration of New England coastal cooking at its most honest and satisfying, and the waterside setting makes every meal feel like a summer memory in the making. Popular with boaters arriving by water, families exploring the island, and locals who know exactly where to go for great seafood. Located on Shelter Island NY, it’s a must-visit on any trip to the island. Come hungry and leave happy.