All Real Estate in Shelter Island

$1,295,000  |  3 Bed  |  2 Bath A beautifully maintained 3-bedroom cottage in Shelter Island Heights with an open floor plan, updated kitchen, wrap-around porch, and a short walk to the beach. This classic island home blends vintage character with modern comfort. Listed by Debra Von Brook-Binder, Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty. View Full Listing Details Read more...

$4,750,000  |  5 Bed  |  4 Bath Stunning 5-bedroom waterfront property with panoramic views of Dering Harbor and Greenport. Deep water dock, heated pool, expansive lawns, and a renovated chef’s kitchen. One of the premier waterfront offerings on Shelter Island. Listed by Debra Von Brook-Binder, Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty. View Full Listing Details Read more...

$695,000 Prime 1.2-acre buildable lot on the desirable south side of Shelter Island with water views and room for a pool. Approved building plans available. A rare opportunity to build your dream island home. Listed by Debra Von Brook-Binder, Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty. View Full Listing Details Read more...